A Compressor Ice Cream Maker offers so much more convenience than any other type of ice cream machine. But there are pros and cons to each model. Don’t buy the wrong one. Here are the details you need to find the best one to suit you.
Quick Links to Info on this Page
- 1. Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker with Compressor – Cuisinart ICE-100
- 2. Whynter Ice Cream Maker – Whynter ICM-200LS
- 3. Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker – Breville BCI600XL
- Compare Cuisinart vs Whynter vs Breville Ice Cream Makers
The advantage of using a compressor ice cream maker is that you don’t need to plan ahead and chill the container. You can also make batch after batch with a compressor machine because you can keep re-using the bowl without chilling it.
1. Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker with Compressor – Cuisinart ICE-100
✅ Click Here for an excellent price on the Cuisinart ICE-100
The Cuisinart ICE-100 Ice Cream Maker with Compressor is a favorite among many. It comes in a brushed stainless steel finish and makes delicious ice cream and gelato.
And it’s fully automatic with a commercial quality compressor.
The aluminum bowl for the Cuisinart ICE-100 has a capacity of 1.5Qt. The lid is clear and locks in place while your ice cream is being made. In the top is a window that opens to add in extras like chocolate chips, nuts or fruit.
The overall weight of this ice cream machine is 32lbs.
The Cuisinart ice cream maker comes with 2 different paddles. Therefore, you’ve got one for making creamy ice cream and the other for making authentic gelato. The components are BPA-free.
The mixing paddles and the lid can be placed on the top shelf of the dishwasher. However, the mixing bowl cannot be placed in the dishwasher. It should be washed by hand without using any abrasive cleaner.
This Cuisinart ICE-100 comes with a 60 minute countdown timer.
And after the timer goes off there’s a 10 minute keep cool function. There’s a blue LCD display.
Cuisinart include a safety feature where the ice cream maker will stop automatically if the motor overheats.
If you add extremely large pieces of nuts or other ingredients this may cause the motor to overheat and you’ll need to give it a break before continuing.
Tip: if you like firmer ice cream you can either place it in the freezer before serving or you can keep it in the compressor ice cream maker. If you start the ice cream machine with 60 minutes on the timer but you press stop after 30 minutes, the compressor will continue to chill until it gets to the 60 minutes.
✅ For an excellent price on the Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker, Click Here
2. Whynter Ice Cream Maker – Whynter ICM-200LS
✅ For an excellent price on the Whynter Ice Cream Machine, Click Here
The Whynter Ice Cream Maker has an aluminum bowl with capacity of 2.1 quarts.
It uses a 180 watt compressor to make your delicious ice cream or rich creamy gelato.
The Whynter compressor ice cream maker uses 3 modes. The Ice Cream Mode will freeze and churn your ice cream mixture for up to 60 minutes.
So, you can set the timer for your desired time anywhere from 5 minutes up to 60 minutes.
In the Cooling Only Mode the machine will freeze the ice cream without the mixing paddle turning.
This mode is set for a default time of 30 minutes. But, the timer can be adjusted before starting this mode.
With the Mixing Only Mode, the paddle will keep turning without the cooling. This mode can be used either for premixing or at the end of making your ice cream when you want to add some extras and they need to be mixed in. The default time is 10 minutes but you can change the timer before starting the mode.
Will my ice cream stay cold?
After your ice cream finishes churning and chilling it will beep and let you know it is going into the Extended Cooling Function to keep the ice cream cold for 10 minutes. It will give 5 beeps at the end of this additional cooling time.
A LCD display shows a timer and temperature display. The bowl and mixing blade are removable for easy cleaning.
Also, this Whynter compressor ice cream maker provides a Motor Protection Function that automatically shuts off to prevent damage if the mixture freezes solid.
✅ For an excellent price on the Whynter Ice Cream Maker, Click Here
3. Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker – Breville BCI600XL
✅ Click Here for the price on this Breville ice cream machine
The Breville BCI600XL is another impressive compressor ice cream maker. It comes with a 1.5 quart bowl capacity. The anodized bowl is removable.
This Breville ice cream machine includes a manual timer which can be set from 5 minutes to 180 minutes. This is great for specific recipes. And there’s a Pre-Cooling function to take the temperature down to between 14°F to -22°F before you start. The Pre-Cool function only takes 5-10 minutes.
There’s a Keep Cool function that will keep your ice cream chilled and churned for up to 3 hours. The paddle will only churn when it is necessary to keep the ice cream churned during the Keep Cool time.
On the Hardness Selection Dial you can select Sorbet, Frozen Yogurt, Gelato or Ice Cream depending on what you’re making and how firm you need it.
When your ice cream is ready you can it will either sound a beep or one of the three musical tunes. You get to choose what you prefer in the settings. There is a volume and tone selection available. You can also place the machine on mute if you don’t want the audible alert.
This smart Breville ice cream machine automatically senses the hardness of the mixture based on your selection and keeps it ready until it’s time to serve. This offers great convenience for you and your family.
There is a flip lid on top to allow you to easily add mix-ins. And you can use the timer to automatically alert you to the right time to add in your favorite mix-ins like choc chips, nuts or fruit.
The lid and the ice cream paddle are dishwasher safe on the top shelf. But the bowl is NOT dishwasher safe. Like most ice cream machines, you’ll need to hand wash it, but it’s very easy to clean.
The LCD display is clear and easy to use.
This display will prompt you depending on what stage your ice cream is at.
At the end it will tell you to Remove the Blade.
And if it is at the pre-cooling stage at the beginning, it will tell you when to Press Start to begin the ice cream making process.
This is a very handy LCD display that goes beyond just showing the countdown timer (which it also does).
This Breville BCI600XL comes with a Progress Indicator Bar so you know what stage it’s got to, and what level of firmness the ice cream has achieved.
This compressor ice cream maker comes with a child lock. It is easy to operate. You only need to press the lock button for 2 seconds to operate it. When you want to unlock it you also hold the lock/unlock button for 2 seconds.
✅ For an excellent price on the Breville Smart Scoop, Click Here
Compare Cuisinart vs Whynter vs Breville Ice Cream Makers
All of the ice cream machines are high quality. But each one doesn’t suit every ice cream lover.
If you have a larger family or you like to make extra to keep in the freezer, you may prefer the Whynter ice cream maker because this machine includes a 2.1 quart bowl for making larger quantities of ice cream.
In comparison, the Cuisinart and Breville machines use 1.5 quart bowls.
Similarly, all the bowls require washing by hand.
Footprint on your counter
Dimensions for the Cuisinart are: 16.73 L x 12 D x 9.33 H inches
The Whynter machine measure: 16.75 L x 11.25 D x 10.25 H inches
The Breville has the following dimensions: 15 3/4 L x 11 D x 11 H inches
As you can see, these ice cream machines are very similar in size. They will take up about the same amount of room on your counter, for instance.
The power for each machine in watts is:
- Cuisinart – about 260 watts (this is based on a calculation of 2.4 amp x 110 volts to get 264 watts – but please correct me if my calculation is wrong. I’m not an electrical engineer or anything similar!!)
- Whynter – 180 watts
- Breville – 165 watts
In comparison the Cuisinart at 23.7 lbs, Whynter at 24.2 lbs and the Breville at 30 lbs, makes the Breville the heaviest. Therefore, the other two compressor ice cream makers are very similar in weight.
If you know you’re going to be frequently lifting the compressor ice cream maker onto your counter from a different height shelf, you may want to consider one of the lighter models.
The biggest differences between these compressor ice cream makers are the settings.
And one of the features that may be most important to you is the duration of the Keep Cool mode on each machine. There is a big difference between them.
Cuisinart offers Keep Cool for 10 minutes after your ice cream is made. Whynter gives you 30 minutes in Keep Cool mode. And Breville lets you keep Cooling the ice cream for up to 3 hours after it is made.
Breville also churns the ice cream during this Keep Cool time automatically when it is required.
Therefore, if you know you’ll use this function, it’s worth making your purchasing decision based on the duration of Keep Cool time you need.
Alignment of Control Panel
The Cuisinart is designed in more of a vertical or portrait alignment. And the control panel is at the top of the machine.
Whereas, the Whynter and Breville machines are more like a horizontal or landscape alignment with the control panel on the right hand side.
For most people the design alignment won’t be an issue on a compressor ice cream maker. But if you know exactly where you want to place your ice cream machine on your counter then this is something that might affect which model you buy.
Each of these compressor ice cream maker machines is high quality and you’ll get delicious ice cream from it. It will come down to personal preference for the settings, weight and control panel alignment of the machine if you want to distinguish between them.
✅ For the price on the Cuisinart, Click Here
✅ For the price on the Whynter, Click Here
✅ And for the price on the Breville, Click Here
⇒ Need an ice cream maker without a compressor? See the best Cuisinart ice cream makers here.